Sunday, November 25, 2012

Crazy Talk

About a week ago, I shared a picture on Facebook from a Facebook group I belong to. The group is called "Common Sense Club" and it is a conservative political group. (A real stretch for me, I know....) The posted picture was this:

OK, somewhat simplistic, but hard to knock the basic principle.

Now I allow comments by total strangers on my Facebook posts, and sure enough, I got not one but two. A Facebook friend of several Facebook friends of mine who I actually know personally for some reason felt moved to post five ranting reasons why this was wrong. Most of it was pretty much socialistic talking points about how corporations abuse people, etc. The gentleman then saw fit to follow up his post by saying something along the lines of "True, because I said it, in spite of Facebook censors." And he "liked" both of his comments.

Goofy, but everyone is entitled to his own opinion, right? Well, here is where I'm a little unsure about the timing of things because as you'll see below, I deleted the gentleman's comments and I can't check back. I don't remember which happened first, but at some point I answered his comment with another comment, stating that businesses were not charities and their sole purpose for their existence was to make money, and either before or after that he sent me a one-word private message: "Fool." He also went on to to continue his commenting on the post, basically saying that they most certainly were not charities, and making more allusions to atrocities.

At this point I stated in the comments that while I welcomed reasonable discussion, he was being abusive. I also responded to his private message by saying, "The weakness of your argument is shown by how quickly you resort to namecalling."

He followed up with another ranting comment on the post in which he threw out insults, said he didn't know me and was glad of that, was sorry that our mutual friends had similar ideas to me especially in light of the fact they were descendants of signers of the Declaration of Independence and that he didn't want me to answer. He also replied to my private message with the following:


No,Mark,
Both my argument,which,but the way you haven't addressed AT ALL, and my name calling are quite accurate,You strike me as one of those unfortunate Republican dupes,who on finding they are [crude sexual reference deleted]
Sad.

I did not intend to let him shut off the conversation (such as it was) in this manner. I deleted his comments from the post because, frankly, I did not want to embarrass our mutual friends by his conduct. I then replied to his private message, and the remainder of that discussion went like this:

ME:  "Please do not respond".... how typical of the left. You say what you want and then attempt to shut down any opposing opinions. You have a lot of abusive things to say about me and yet as you say, you do not know me. You are hate-filled and abusive and I pity you.
Oh, and by the way, those signers of the Declaration - pretty much the "1%" of their day.
·         

OTHER GUY:  I pity your naive ignorance,Mr. McMillen.You have said what you want in your,I am sure,well-meant post which borders on the kindly fascistic.I do hate ignorance,especially passionately believed and stated.
BTW:The signer to whom I was referring was a man of comfortable means,a lawyer,but by no means rich.
Finally,and this will be my last comment to you:I find your insinuation that those disenfranchised and reliant on state aid are at fault for their poverty hateful and abusive toward humanity.Please read Yeats' "Slouching Towards Bethlehem" and see the documentary film:"Inside Job".


ME:  "Fewer people on gov't assistance + more people working = higher tax revenue" - offensive how? There is no imputed reason why people are on government assistance or any condemnation of them implied by that statement. You're filtering that through your own biases.
Moreover, regardless of what hot buttons that pushes for you or what you think of the political philosophy that originated it, it's clearly a true statement. OBVIOUSLY more people working are going to generate more tax revenue.
I have been polite and tolerant of you. In the meantime you have insulted me, called me ignorant, and used crude sexual slurs at me; you've pigeonholed me into a group that you hate without even knowing me, and accused me of insinuations that I did not make. Not only that, you have gone out of your way to do this. And may I remind you that you responded to something I posted that was not even directed to you. You are an abuser. I suggest you get help.
I thought that liberals/progressives/the left were tolerant, at least that's what they've always told us.
·         

OTHER GUY:  I asked you not to reply,Mr. McMillen.Your post appeared in my newsfeed as liked by [mutual friend].You are the ABUSER. FURTHER MESSAGES FROM YOU WILL BE DELETED.I MAY REPORT YOU TO FACEBOOK.
Goodbye/Good Riddance
·         

ME:  Well feel free. We can see whose messages they think are abusive.

At this point I blocked the individual. I half hoped he would report me to Facebook, but if he did I was not made aware of it.

I know that people have different views than I do; I know that some hate big business for abuses that have been committed and they have a point; I'm more than willing to discuss differences and how effective big government is at controlling those abuses (can you say Hitler, Stalin and Mao?). But this guy was just talking crazy talk.