Sunday, July 6, 2014

Why Not Term Limits?

It's been about a year and a half since I posted anything explicitly political, not counting a swipe I took at the present occupant of the White House last May, so maybe Independence Day weekend is a good time for another political post.

Term limits are very popular with the American people, according to most if not all polls; see, for example, this one from Gallup. In that particular poll, 75% would vote for term limits. Among conservatives, the number is even higher (82%).

Recently in my neighborhood, one of the local members of the state legislature, Daryl Metcalfe (arguably the most conservative member of the statehouse), was challenged in the primary by an opponent who pushed the term limits idea.

Well, I have to break ranks with the majority of my fellow Americans and my conservative fellow travellers.

In this link by Larry Reams, you will find an argument for term limits from a conservative point of view. The author correctly points out that the Founders did not include term limits in the Constitution, essentially saying that you shouldn't throw the baby out with the bathwater. There was by no means unanimous agreement on this, however. At any rate, the author goes on to say that good behavior of the elected officials was assuemed, and since we no longer have that, it's time to change. That is an oversimplification of the article but you can read it if you want the details.

The author makes some very good points, and I would say that it is a very rare individual who can be in the center of government without losing touch with the constituents he or she is supposed to be serving.

As a counterpoint, read this article  by Richard Winchester for the contrarian view, also from a conservative viewpoint. The writer of this article addresses both the pros and cons of term limits, and ends up on the con side. And in my opinion, he makes good arguments for that case.

I am opposed to term limits for the following reasons:

1. There are some good politicians. Probably not many. But why should they have to be kicked out if they are in fact doing a good job?

2. A higher turnover in the elected offices would give more power to the unelected bureaucrats behind the scenes. If the politicians are less experienced, the bureaucrats will be running the show to an even greater extent than they already do.

3. We already have term limits. The term of a Representative is two years. The term of a Senator is six years. At the end of those terms, each of those individuals has to face re-election. If the citizenry re-elects a schmuck for another term, whose fault is that? And if the citizenry cannot be trusted not to re-elect a schmuck with his or her record in front of them, how can they be trusted to make the right choice for somebody with no record?

Of course, as Winchester puts it, "for elections to work as instruments for term limits something will have to change: citizens' habitual indifference to, and ignorance of, Congress and its denizens." That means we have to get off our collective lazy butts and actually be engaged in the political process, instead of just voting for the same doofuses over and over again and then complaining how we need term limits.

This is my opinion; what about yours?

That's about it, for now.